What engineers should know about crystalline silica in construction

Image: Getty

Construction workers being diagnosed with silicosis in their 30s is unacceptable, and something needs to change, says engineer and occupational hygienist Kate Cole OAM AffilIEAust.

As told to Lachlan Haycock

The heavy media focus given to silicosis in recent years has led to people considering it solely an issue to do with engineered stone.

While it is true there are very high rates of disease caused by that incredibly toxic product – in one Australian state, as many as one in every four people who have worked with engineered stone has been diagnosed with a silica-related disease – it’s not the only substance engineers need to look out for.

Back in 2022, researchers at Curtin University predicted up to around 100,000 cases of silicosis and at least 10,000 cases of lung cancer due to exposure to crystalline silica in the workplace.

Given how large the mining and construction industries are in Australia, and how many of those workers are exposed to silica dust, they represent quite a large proportion of that estimate of 100,000 workers.

Hidden hazard

The risks around working at height, working in or around water, or when people are interacting with large-scale machinery, are quite obvious. If you were to look at a construction site and notice a wall has fallen down, it’s clear what’s gone wrong.

With dust, the danger can be significantly less obvious.

I started out my career as a site engineer on construction projects, but I’ve seen this issue play out through a number of different lenses. The main areas I’ve worked in are remediation of contaminated land, construction, demolition, and tunnelling.

“If you were to look at a construction site and notice a wall has fallen down, it's quite obvious what’s gone wrong. With dust, it can be significantly less obvious.”
Kate Cole

What’s clear to me is that – while there are many health and safety hazards that engineers manage on a day-to-day basis during the design, construction and operation of assets – we tend to, as a community, focus a lot more on overt safety hazards than we do on hazards that can impact our health. This is interesting because those are the hazards that actually cause more fatalities in the workplace.

Part of the problem is that the effects of exposure to this hazardous chemical can take years or decades to manifest into disease, so the risk may not be recognised if awareness is limited.

Dust particle sizes. Image: Safe Work Australia, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence

In practice

There are two resources to which I routinely direct engineers seeking to learn more.

The first is the code of practice for the safe design of structures. That’s the obvious one. I’d recommend reading it through the lens of the silica dust risk, not the more general safety lens engineers probably use to read it the first time.

The second is the crystalline silica substances regulation. It’s very specific, very prescriptive, and it’s like that for an important reason.

But beyond this, there’s an extra layer to consider. When at university, engineers don’t necessarily learn how things are actually done in practice. We learn how they’re theoretically done. We learn what should be done, but not always how it’s really done. There’s a gap between work as imagined versus work as done.

Spending time talking with, listening to and observing the work of workers – and understanding how their work is actually being carried out – is critical.

Construction workers being diagnosed with silicosis at the age of 32 is unacceptable. If we want this to change, then we need to do something drastically different. We need to place this risk at the front of our minds when considering all the health and safety risks that are posed during the design, development, construction and operation of our country’s assets.

Rock-solid approach?

We’ll always have to dig into rock that contains silica. We can’t avoid that. It’s a given. There will also be a need to use silica-containing products such as concrete, and we can’t get away from that either. But there is still the opportunity to replace some of these silica-containing products with silica-free products.

I’m talking about silica-free grouts. Stones that don’t contain crystalline silica. Maybe it’s a less hazardous form such as amorphous silica, or maybe there’s no silica in it at all. What can be done at time of design to preferentially select products that are less hazardous to the workers using them?

Early in the design process, engineers generally have control – in consultation with other stakeholders of course – over what can reasonably be done to address this. Making such decisions at the time of construction is rarely practicable. That’s when the design is already set in stone, if you pardon the pun.

“The sheer number of cases of silicosis and other silica-related diseases evident in Australia has raised awareness of the importance of this issue.”
Kate Cole

It’s not only looking at the materials, but how something is built. Is there different machinery that can be used to reduce the risk to workers? If workers must operate the machinery, can they do so remotely? If not, can they operate it in an enclosed and pressurised environment that prevents exposure to dust? What other options do we have?

We are not going to get anywhere as a society by simply relying on respiratory protection or dust masks, no matter how fantastic they are. That’s not to suggest they’re not needed, but we’re going to need bigger gains in reducing the burden of silicosis and related diseases in our country through implementing engineering interventions.

Unfortunately, the sheer number of cases of silicosis and other silica-related diseases evident in Australia has raised awareness of the importance of this issue. It’s resulted in some really important regulatory reforms, the ban on engineered stone being one and the introduction of the crystalline silica regulations being another.

Kate Cole OAM AffilIEAust is a Certified Occupational Hygienist, the former President of the Australian Institute of Occupational Hygienists, and has advised government and industry bodies such as the NSW Dust Diseases Board, and the Asbestos and Silica Safety and Eradication Council.

Watch Kate Cole outline the crystalline silica challenge further in this webinar.

Exit mobile version