CREATE
  • Technology
    • BIOTECH
    • COMMUNICATIONS
    • COMPUTING
    • IMAGING
    • MATERIALS
    • ROBOTICS
    • SOFTWARE
  • Industry
    • DEFENCE
    • INFRASTRUCTURE
    • INNOVATION
    • MANUFACTURING
    • POLICY
    • PROJECTS
    • TRANSPORT
  • Sustainability
    • ENERGY
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • RESOURCES
  • Community
    • CULTURE
    • PEOPLE
  • Career
    • EDUCATION
    • INSPIRATION
    • LEADERSHIP
    • TRENDS
  • About
    • CONTACT
    • SUBSCRIBE
No Result
View All Result
CREATE
  • Technology
    • BIOTECH
    • COMMUNICATIONS
    • COMPUTING
    • IMAGING
    • MATERIALS
    • ROBOTICS
    • SOFTWARE
  • Industry
    • DEFENCE
    • INFRASTRUCTURE
    • INNOVATION
    • MANUFACTURING
    • POLICY
    • PROJECTS
    • TRANSPORT
  • Sustainability
    • ENERGY
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • RESOURCES
  • Community
    • CULTURE
    • PEOPLE
  • Career
    • EDUCATION
    • INSPIRATION
    • LEADERSHIP
    • TRENDS
  • About
    • CONTACT
    • SUBSCRIBE
No Result
View All Result
CREATE
No Result
View All Result
Home Career Education

Do HSCs measure up to the demands of engineering degrees?

Sameer Murthy by Sameer Murthy
21 November 2017
in Education, Opinion
Reading Time: 3 mins read
1
Do HSCs measure up to the demands of engineering degrees?

HSC physics left me and others ill-prepared for our engineering degrees, which begs the question: What needs to happen to narrow the gap between high school and university courses?

The NSW Board of Studies rightly comes under heavy scrutiny and criticism every year. After all, they play a huge part in the short-term future of more than 35,000 HSC students each year. This time however, they must be praised for changing the HSC physics curriculum, and hinting that the HSC physics content from the past 15 years had negative consequences for students.

This move has the potential to narrow the gap between HSC science and first-year university courses. As noted physicist Michelle Simmons has previously stated, the old physics curriculum left many students ill-prepared for what was to come in their tertiary studies.

Harsh reality

For many students like me who had some idea that they wished to study in a quantitative discipline like engineering, the recommended subjects from university guides to enrol in include Extension 2 mathematics (hardest level of maths) and physics, while chemistry is also suggested.

I followed the latter two, but the temptation of wanting to cruise through year 11 and 12 meant that I took the ‘easier’ option of Extension 1 mathematics. To an extent, I found I was able to use the same studying technique for HSC mathematics for the maths courses at university, which is just establishing muscle memory by repetitively attempting exercises.

Science courses did not allow for that luxury. For example in the 2015 HSC physics exam – the year I sat it – one question asked how Heinrich Hertz set his experiments to prove James Maxwell’s theory that light was a form of electromagnetic experiment. This is more of an exercise in rote learning, rather than applying any logic.

If this is the kind of question an Australian school student was getting in their most important physics exam at that stage of their life, is it any wonder that Australia is behind countries like Kazakstan, Slovenia and Lithuania in the global year 8 science rankings?

University physics in the first year is much more about thinking for yourself as opposed to having the work cut out for you, which is crucial for engineering degrees. I was not used to this and found myself struggling to apply how first principles and calculus are used to derive formulas.

To be honest, it was probably through the generosity of physics tutors and senior engineering students who took time out to explain difficult concepts that allowed get me through the course. To go from reciting history in HSC physics one year to trying to work out the meaning of Schrodinger’s equation in quantum mechanics the next year is no mean feat!

Aligned with the times

There were many other issues under the old physics curriculum that defied common sense. One instance of this was how the syllabus involved learning about cathode-ray tubes, which is a dying technology, as opposed to covering photonics in more depth, which has far more relevance today when considering the current importance of renewable energy.

The mainstream media is always hammering on about the need for students to go into more STEM degrees, but in the past fifteen years, the secondary school system in NSW wasn’t providing students the basics for their chosen field at tertiary-level education.

There are going to be challenges in the new curriculum if it does turn out to be more mathematical based. As noted previously on The Conversation, schools that are on the lower socio-economic end of the spectrum will struggle to find the resources to adequately teach their students, compared to elite private schools, where students have access to the best tutors and facilities.

However, I think the re-introduction of topics such as optics and thermodynamics in HSC physics will be hugely beneficial, as these topics are extensively taught in early year university courses.

Students who have an interest in science, technology, maths or engineering degrees will be better prepared to make a decision based on their HSC experiences, rather than racking up a years worth of HECS debt only to learn that their chosen subjects are unrecognisable at university.

Tags: HSCSTEMtertiary education
Previous Post

Can this unique approach help more parents achieve better work-life balance?

Next Post

How can engineering graduates get out of the classroom and straight into a job?

Sameer Murthy

Sameer Murthy

Sameer Murthy studies electrical engineering at University of Sydney. In his spare time, he likes to read and play cricket.

Related Posts

It starts with maths: How to get more young people studying engineering
Education

It starts with maths: How to get more young people studying engineering

28 July 2026
Australia has a maths problem that training more engineers can help fix
Education

Australia has a maths problem that training more engineers can help fix

16 April 2026
An expert weighs in on saving engineering’s reputation
Education

An expert weighs in on saving engineering’s reputation

16 January 2025
Next Post
How can engineering graduates get out of the classroom and straight into a job?

How can engineering graduates get out of the classroom and straight into a job?

Comments 1

  1. Ans. M. says:
    2 weeks ago

    They haven’t changed sht.

    The Syllabus That Rewards Remembering

    A physics examination makes a promise about what the subject is. Its marks say what the examiners think a physicist does with an hour. Measured this way, the Higher School Certificate in Physics describes a discipline that is mostly recited, and its calculation is shallow even where it appears.

    The 2025 paper is the clearest case. Only about two-fifths of its marks, 41%, ask a candidate to calculate anything. Of those, 4% are difficult by the standard of a problem whose route the candidate must find. Essays that run half a page or more account for 31% of the paper. The long answers are worth roughly eight times the share given to hard problems. A student could write confidently about the history of the atom and the nature of light, and still never meet a problem that required inventing a method.

    The sibling papers do not redeem this. In 2024, calculation was 35% and the difficult share was zero. In 2026, calculation was 38% and the difficult share was again zero, while essays took a quarter of the paper. The 2023 paper reached 7% difficult and 39% calculation. The 2020 paper reached 4.5% and 41.5%. The best recent year offers the hardest problem at under a tenth of the marks. The state’s own 2016 and 2018 papers, taken with the one option a science school would sit, held calculation at 15% and 24%. Even by that standard, the recent papers are an improvement only by comparison.

    The comparison with other jurisdictions is the cruelest part of the data. Western Australia’s 2025 paper is about 80% calculation, with about 9% difficult and no essays. Tasmania sits near 66%, South Australia near 63%, Queensland near 56%, and Victoria near 54%. These are different systems with different aims, but all of them ask more of a student’s mathematics than New South Wales does. Nor was it always so. The 1995 Rotation paper was 57% calculation and the 2000 paper was 73.5%, both without an essay. The state once asked for more arithmetic and less prose than it does now.

    The schools themselves supply the best evidence. The selective-school trial examinations for 2025 and the years around it read like corrections to the state paper. Girraween’s 2025 trial is 64% calculation with 17% difficult. North Sydney Boys, on an 80-mark task, reaches about 74% calculation with 20% difficult. Sydney Boys has 15% difficult, and James Ruse’s 2022 trial has 14.5%. Abbotsleigh’s 2025 trial is 21% difficult. Those schools evidently do not believe that the state examination measures what a candidate needs, and they supplement it with problems of their own. A syllabus that is serving its students does not need the best schools to correct its examination in advance. The State, in effect, outsources its rigour to whoever can afford it.

    The fault lies partly in the syllabus. Its outcomes use the verbs explain, discuss, analyse and assess far more freely than derive or calculate. It attaches long stretches of historical content to the physics, such as Thomson’s cathode rays, Rutherford’s model, Chadwick’s neutron and Maxwell’s field, and each stretch invites a paragraph in place of a derivation. The effect is a course in which a student may meet the correct equation, state it, and move on without ever being forced to use it under pressure. The examiners then write what the syllabus gives them. A paper made from those outcomes will tend to ask for prose, because prose is what the outcomes ask for.

    The cost falls on the student who goes on to study physics or engineering. Universities teach by problem. The first-year student is asked to carry an unfamiliar situation through several stages to a number or a derived expression, with the route unstated. The HSC, as the data shows, seldom asks for that in its own right, and the paper’s best recent showing of it is a single question in 2023. The student arrives fluent in what physicists once believed, and often unpractised in what physicists do. The candidate who writes an essay well is rewarded by the exam. The university never measures that skill.

    A fair reading admits what the data cannot show. Marks describe an examination’s format and not the quality of teaching, and a diligent teacher can build problem-solving into the course whatever the paper does. The syllabus claim here is an inference from the examination and not from a reading of the syllabus text. The essay share also moves from year to year, at 14% in 2023, 15% in 2024, and 31% in 2025, so the trend is not a straight line. What does not move is the ceiling. Across seven recent years of the state’s own paper, the share of difficult calculation never exceeds 7%, and calculation as a whole never exceeds 42%. A subject that calls itself physics should not be satisfied with so little.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

create is brought to you by Engineers Australia, Australia's national body for engineers and the voice of more than 120,000 members. Backing today's problem-solvers so they can shape a better tomorrow.
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • SITEMAP
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS
  • SUBSCRIBE

© 2024 Engineers Australia

No Result
View All Result
  • Technology
    • BIOTECH
    • COMMUNICATIONS
    • COMPUTING
    • IMAGING
    • MATERIALS
    • ROBOTICS
    • SOFTWARE
  • Industry
    • DEFENCE
    • INFRASTRUCTURE
    • INNOVATION
    • MANUFACTURING
    • POLICY
    • PROJECTS
    • TRANSPORT
  • Sustainability
    • ENERGY
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • RESOURCES
  • Community
    • CULTURE
    • PEOPLE
  • Career
    • EDUCATION
    • INSPIRATION
    • LEADERSHIP
    • TRENDS
  • About
    • CONTACT
    • SUBSCRIBE